Building Power · Season 1 · Article 1
But We Do Good Work
Why social policy research organizations still need unions
By Jalen Alexander
I was standing in my living room when a colleague called. It was during the pandemic, when so many of us in New York and across the country were working from home. We already had a good rapport, so the conversation felt familiar. They asked how I was doing, how things were going at MDRC, and what I thought could be better about the organization.
By then, I had been at MDRC for less than two years. Before the pandemic, I had received consistently positive feedback on my work but struggled to get clear answers about how that translated into a path to advancement. I had also spent months going back and forth with my manager about working from home one day a week. That flexibility, I was told, was reserved for more senior staff, though I couldn’t find that rule plainly written anywhere. My manager, meanwhile, worked remotely across the country.
During those conversations, my manager questioned for the first time whether MDRC was a good workplace fit for me. I was asking how I could advance and why I couldn’t work from home one day a week. From my perspective, the conversation had become about whether I belonged there rather than whether the policies could change.
Then the pandemic sent everyone home. Looking back, the months of debate felt even more frustrating: so many hours spent protecting “the way things have always been,” only for that arrangement to change for everyone. Who got flexibility, who could move forward, and who got to decide were already questions I was carrying into that call.
We talked about what I felt was working well and quite a bit about what wasn’t. They shared questions about how things got done at MDRC, how quickly, and how transparently. Then my colleague told me that some people were considering unionizing. Was I interested?
I said yes. I also said yes to helping organize: having conversations with other coworkers like the one we had just had. What excited me was the possibility that the people doing the work could have a bigger say in how our workplace functioned.
The mission and the workplace
Before I joined MDRC, people in research told me it was a prestigious place to work. That reputation was part of the context we were organizing in. When an organization is highly regarded, working there can become part of how people understand their own accomplishments. Being hired feels like an achievement. Challenging the workplace can become harder when you feel fortunate to be there.
MDRC is a social policy research organization whose work focuses on people with low incomes. The idea behind that work is that high-quality research and evidence can help reduce poverty and expand opportunity. That mission mattered to me. I had worked in mission-driven nonprofits before. I knew the feeling that came with being around people who wanted to do good in the world.
But an organization doing good work can easily be assumed to be a good place to work. The mission alone doesn’t tell you how decisions are made, whose concerns receive attention, or what opportunities workers have to advance. We were the people carrying out the work that drove that mission every day. Our experiences and knowledge deserved to help shape the organization, too.
For me, caring about the mission included caring about the conditions under which we pursued it. If we were committed to improving people’s lives through our research, that commitment should also have something to say about how we treated the people doing the research and supporting the organization.
That did not mean everyone experienced MDRC the same way. It meant we needed to take those differences seriously, including experiences that were easy to miss from our own desks or departments.
Being asked without seeing change
As I look back on that period, I remember repeated efforts to understand the organization’s culture. External consultants interviewed staff and held focus groups. Questions came up about retention, promotion, pay, and transparency. How did people move up? How were raises determined? What explained differences in pay?
These were questions staff were already asking. Consultants would gather our experiences and bring them back to management in reports. Sometimes we saw a report; other times we saw only portions of it. From where I sat, it was difficult to see how the recurring concerns were leading to changes, or to understand what follow-through we should expect.
I became frustrated with that cycle. We had given feedback through interviews, surveys, and conversations. The concerns were familiar. I wanted to know what would make the next round different.
There were also limits to what we could understand on our own. Before the pandemic, I saw coworkers in the halls and cafeteria, coming into the office and leaving in the evening. But we were not comparing actual salary figures, even with people in similar roles. We could have questions about fairness without enough information to assess them together.
That was a difficult position for a workplace full of inquisitive analysts and researchers. We knew how important information was to understanding a problem. Yet when it came to our own working conditions, much of what we needed was not readily available to us.
Organizing gave us another way to ask questions. In one-on-one conversations, we could begin comparing experiences instead of holding each concern separately. If one person found promotions unclear and another described the same uncertainty, we had something to explore together. We were starting to understand which questions extended beyond our individual situations.
Different reasons to hesitate
Some coworkers were eager to get involved. I remember particular interest among people who had been at MDRC for only a year or two. Some brought experience from other workplaces; for others, this was an early job. They had not spent years getting used to the way things were done here, and the possibility of changing them seemed easier to imagine.
Other conversations were more delicate. Some longtime staff described the organization as family. They had felt supported by people in management and worried that organizing would hurt those relationships or be taken as disrespect. Interestingly, many staff in this group feared punishment and expressed a sense of low job security. I had to understand that their concerns about attachment and potential retaliation were real, even when my conclusions were different.
There were also some people who could see a path upward for themselves within the existing system. They knew how to work toward advancement and felt that staying in management’s good graces would keep them on the fast-track. Those conversations pushed us to think beyond whether the workplace was working for any one of us. What responsibility did we have to coworkers whose experience was different? Could we care about people outside the organization while overlooking the people working beside us?
Then there were people who had little confidence that anything would change. They had seen concerns raised before with workgroups formed and recommendations shared to no avail. Asking them to imagine workers coming together and improving the organization meant asking them to believe in a possibility they had lost reason to expect.
Someone afraid of losing their job, someone comfortable with how the system rewarded them, and someone who had lost hope were bringing different concerns to those conversations. I could not assume that just explaining my own reasons for wanting to unionize once would settle theirs.
I understood firsthand the social tensions that could arise from challenging norms. Asking what felt like straightforward questions about career advancement or work flexibility had led to questions about whether I belonged at the organization. That experience helped me understand why someone might see a problem and still hesitate to speak up. But I also saw pushing back as an expression of care. Wanting things to change meant I still believed the workplace could be better, and that we could help make it better together.
Even people who supported unions in principle sometimes struggled to picture one in their own workplace. They might have a family member in a union, or value what unions had done elsewhere, without yet seeing why we needed one at MDRC. Asking them directly also made the conversation vulnerable. I was revealing where I stood, and they were being asked to consider where they stood too.
People wanted to know whether others were interested. They wanted to know they would not be alone. Building that confidence took time, return conversations, and a willingness to listen to answers that were still taking shape.
Learning to imagine change together
Joining the organizing team was encouraging for me. Here were coworkers who looked different, sounded different, and brought different experiences, but were willing to work together for a greater say in the workplace. Many of us had never belonged to a union or worked in a unionized organization. We were learning while we were doing it.
Our research habits helped. We were curious. We asked people what was going well and what needed to improve. We wanted to understand who felt welcome, who could see a future at the organization, and what might lead someone to leave. Those were questions to investigate, not conclusions we could assume we already knew.
The early organizing team (huge shoutout to all those amazing peeps!) deserves credit for doing that work across roles and departments, including research, administration, and IT. Our partners at AFSCME helped coach us on one-on-one conversations and the importance of going back to people. Coworkers made those conversations possible by sharing experiences that could be difficult to discuss.
Seeing other people take that work seriously changed what felt possible. It could happen over many meetings, but sometimes a single conversation seemed to help someone see things differently. I learned that I could not know in advance which conversation would matter most. We had to keep making room for people to think, ask questions, and become involved.
We wanted to improve the organization we had chosen to work for. The people interested in forming a union were already part of its mission. We wanted our knowledge of the workplace to count, and we wanted a meaningful role in addressing the concerns we kept raising.
It’s the people with a sense of mission that formed the union.
That conviction did not make every conversation easy or resolve every disagreement. We still had to work out what we wanted together. But in those early days, I could see coworkers beginning to believe that we could do more than just describe the problems. We could organize to change them.
What the mission asks of us
If you work in a mission-driven organization, I would start by asking who makes decisions about your working life. Does feedback travel upward while decisions come back down? Where do workers participate in making those decisions? When the same concerns keep surfacing, what happens next?
You can appreciate your workplace and challenge it to grow. People make mistakes, and sometimes the ways we work allow those mistakes to become patterns. A worthwhile mission does not relieve us of the responsibility to notice them.
Calling out systemic problems does not make you a problem!
That phone call in my living room opened a possibility for me. The conversations that followed helped us begin to see our experiences together and imagine having more say in what happened next. That was where organizing began for me, before recognition or a first contract: with coworkers asking what could be better and taking one another’s answers seriously.
The question I want to leave with you is the one I keep returning to: Is your workplace pursuing its mission with the same care for the people doing the work as for the people it hopes to serve?